Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Sunday, 25 January 2026

No Full Stops in India -Only commas and questions : A Book Review






While I was finishing school and getting into college, this was the man whose English and politics was what I loved to hear and read about. Getting that opportunity was not very easy, though. This is about life in Cuttack, Orissa of the Seventies. Catching BBC was prized and something to boast about amongst friends. We could understand what he spoke - an accent one related to easily. Reading, Mark Tully in one of the dailies or in some magazine was celebration. Nothing or no one could be better for us natives. .Later on, the days of the television, though, made him so much more familiar.

"No Full Stops in India”
is yet another series of stories strung together about: India and its people” by the loveable, itinerant raconteur, the irrepressible Mr. Mark Tully. Published by the Penguin in the early nineties he travels through the length and breadth of India, picks and chooses places, events and people to reiterate his firm conviction that India is alive and well. In all of over the, three hundred pages spread over several chapters his compassion for the ordinary man comes through, sincere and passionate. He chides his “white” peers like an indignant, self righteous cousin for having failed to understand the real India and thus, wronged an ancient and proud civilization.

Having done his schooling and for the better part of his professional career being posted
In India Mark takes us on a special journey which most of us Indians are yet, to make. Not quite the sophisticated and erudite discovery that of a Nehru or the utter prostrations of anything British a la Nirad Babu but more akin to the simple and natural R K Laxman .Slowly but surely, he leads you on through the eyes of his “help” Ram Chander to the heart of India- Gavvan Village close to lucknow :Taxi stands, potholed roads, tractors carrying generators and tables and chairs, the marriage ceremonies of Ram and the stay in the harijan basti with Gillian, his companion, the Indian whiskies, the cheap country liquor and open air latrines. All along you enjoy the ride, never suspecting the felicity and feeling with which Mark introduces you to your very own darkest subject that of the Harijan, their lives and society.

He talks of the “new colonialism” of preventing the development of a native Indian self confidence thru’ the conflicts and dilemmas, of the famed sculptor Stapati with the equally famous Stephen Cox, of Father Kunakkals’ principled defence of Hindi as the language for national Identity and the harm caused by English to the latter and the difficulties in the emergence of the Dalit Christians and a new theology. He underlines with deep felt conviction that religion did not make communities communal on the basis of the spectacular success of the Ramayana serial across religious divides. On the contrary, the westernized import of secularism was ill suited to the needs of modern India, he avers.

A first hand account of Operation Black Thunder unravels all the pain and travails of the modern Sikh youth and the hapless flip flopping of the Congress party in resolving the Sikh Militancy. The Red Bengal gets a sympathetic ear along with a radical view on the “Deorala affair” and the rise of women empowerment. The humongous and utterly incredible throng of Indian Sadhus in Kumbh Mela is counterposed by the more sad and sobering existence post the communal riots in Gujrat.He sees very early the tragedy of the Tribal and sensitively talks of the challenges ahead in the mines and forests of Central India while interacting with their authentic wards. Finally, he meets his great friend Digvijay Singh of Bihar to round off his politico-social travelogue to convince us all of the need “of a modern order but not a slavish imitation of other”

Each chapter is a theme of modern India, written exquisitely and graphically enough to be filmed. Another “Bharat Ek khoj” perhaps. Every Indian needs to read and own a copy to understand the growth and history of the modern Indian society. Everyone else, too : to notice the lack of any condescension, arrogance or superciliousness in the understanding of India as a nation and society.


Sunday, 21 April 2024

The verdict on Ayodhya: a historian's perspective - The Hindu






What happened in history, happened. It cannot be changed. But we can learn to understand what happened in its fuller context and strive to look at it on the basis of reliable evidence. We cannot change the past to justify the politics of the present. The verdict has annulled respect for history and seeks to replace history with religious faith. True reconciliation can only come when there is confidence that the law in this country bases itself not just on faith and belief, but on evidence.

The verdict on Ayodhya: a historian's perspective - The Hindu

Thursday, 5 February 2015

# Bhai :Experiments with Truth of a different Mahatma



It is interesting and not without a touch of irony can it be said that the country that has launched the girl-child programme from haryana to arrest the girl-boy child ratio ostensibly at the behest of the current Prime Minister seems to be himself in quite a quandary on issues regarding the status of women, girl , child-marriage, women-empowerment, masculinity and patriarchy et all when seen in his personal life.
India is admittedly a country of contrasts with great freedom of women seen amongst the elite and tribals at the lowest level vis-a- vis the majority where systematic inequality prevails on such matters among other things.

India along with Narendra bhai is evolving.So is everyone else.Women the world are unequally positioned, more so in our country.Child marriages are yet to be a thing of the past and still happen.Some great men grew from such marriages i read.Some , if not most played havoc with their wives and some like Bhai were caught in a prevalent social practice out of obedience, loyalty or pure inability to withstand an offer due to sheer lack of choice.He remained celibate when he could have re-married any time later.These thoughts are, of course in the realm of conjecture.They did not cohabit is what the family says but would be an intimate truth known only to the persons concerned.Bhai would have none of it when perhaps he was more confident and clear about his desires and motivations and gradually perhaps moved away from this union of sorts.But he was still left with a memory of an uncomfortable fact.What could he do? Accept and reconcile or legally separate.In both ways I would imagine would have caused no solutions or brought happiness.Bhai is trapped in his past, inadequacies of age and passage of time within an ambivalent world tragic and a farce together.Jashoda behn remains the traditional loyalist with fond hopes like many more such waiting for the prodigal husband.What can Bhai do, after all?


Shall we wait to see the last word said or deed done in the future or live with an honest admission that all of us men in the final analysis have our little dark corners where we live alone in impotent dilemmas and sad at that, maybe ?At least, some of us that is.


No offense meant, to women really !your crosses you carry for sure which are admittedly, worse.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/abandoned-as-a-child-bride-indias-first-lady-still-hopes-her-husband-will-call/2015/01/25/3509dac5-5ac1-49e3-8b44-7d92e027c9ec_story.html

Sunday, 22 June 2014

Standing on the shoulders of a giant !

The Discovery of IndiaThe Discovery of India by Jawaharlal Nehru
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

As a child I read it and was overwhelmed by the style , depth and feeling of a man who while having belonged to the aristocracy had been sucked into the rough and tumble of the Freedom Movement and chose, as if by destiny, to give his all.He narrates his view of India, its past, present and a future from behind the jails that he so often found himself to be in.
While so much has been written post independence,The serial Bharat Ek Khoj by Shyam Benegal based on this book further reconfirmed my ardour for this book to be honest,reverent and understanding of an old culture and civilisation that survives, lives and breathes to envision a legitimate and bright future.
A must read for anyone who loves or hates India.


View all my reviews

Saturday, 14 June 2014

China :An enigma, wrapped in mystery



China is many things to many Indians.The proverbial elephant felt and described by blind men, perhaps  To the neo-liberal intelligentsia who love and dream to see India big and stronger than China, a successful, but impious Dragon,to the rising but politically indifferent awed by its growth and rapid success an inscrutable and non-transparent behemoth, to the traditional and conservative who hate all that is Chinese 'coz they have been told that they attacked India and annexed and hold many of our territories, a Judas and to some a cultural junior what with Hieun Tsang having visited India some thousands of years ago to see the "milk and honey and the twittering golden-bird on every branch and bough". A miniscule left leaning workers and academia look at it for succor and political leadership,the Chinese Master in a manner of speaking.

Many complain they get to know nothing.See very little and hear in garbled and unclear whispers: the story that is China.Anything good or encouraging is met with distrust and the random running down of their achievements with the high fives of deja vu. So what is the truth?How does one get to know of China more to learn and understand in the usual milk run of life? Surely one does not wish to be overloaded with heaps of literature and information from various sources to unburden one's ignorance.

To understand more without much ado of what India can learn or undo in times to come.While China firmly plants its friendly flag in many nations more for goodwill and less for profit,it is keen to understand the tricky and sometimes intractable ways of private ownership, property,laws of succession, inter-racial marriages, adoption etc of foreign lands.It is also understood that in the latest visit of the Chinese Premier in a private, confidential meeting held with senior Indian Land/revenue officials the former showed more than a casual interest in the subject.So are the Chinese coming to India while we travel too, to see and believe what we hear ? Interesting times ahead..

In this little  excerpt from "China's Second Continent": Howard French presents a tongue-in-cheek political cum insightful travelogue on the Chinese people and their ordinary and sometimes large ambitions, its party,government and politics in building International Solidarity with their manufacturing and industrial skills on export as the most potent and real-time face of their proud nation among other things.

An interesting take of a past and I quote"Young people in China today no longer learn bow to chiku,”he said. The expression means to “eat bitterness,” to endure great hardship. “I want my son to become a real man, a worthy person.”

Click on the link below to know more.



http://qz.com/217597